生平

882年，馮道生於瀛州的景城，他自稱為始平（在今陝西省）、長樂（今河北省冀州市）二郡世族馮氏的後人。馮道出生在「為農為儒，不恆其業」的家庭，青年時孝順好學，不恥清貧，性格節儉刻苦。唐末天祐年間，馮道曾任盧龍節度使劉守光的參軍。劉守光率軍征討定州，並詢問僚屬意見。馮道加以勸諭，惹怒劉守光而下獄。劉守光兵敗後，他逃到太原投靠當時在河東任監軍使的宦官張承業，當了巡官。後張承業把他推薦給晉王李存勗，不久兼任河東節度掌書記。李存勗與後梁交戰，曾下令馮道撰寫罷免前線指揮郭崇韜的文書，馮道因當面諫阻李存勗而贏得聲望。

923年，李存勗即位，建立後唐，授馮道為省郎，充翰林學士。李存勗滅後梁後，任命馮道為戶部侍郎。後馮道因服父喪而歸鄉，期間幾乎被契丹擄走。926年，李嗣源在李存勗死後繼位，重新起用馮道為端明殿學士，後又升遷為中書侍郎、刑部尚書平章事，相當於宰相之位。933年，李嗣源駕崩，兒子李從厚繼位。四個月後，李嗣源義子、潞王李從珂起兵造反。馮道知道皇帝逃往父婿石敬瑭的軍中後，並未前去護駕，而是率百官迎接從珂，於是從珂順利登基，是為後唐末帝（934年）。但李從珂沒有重用馮道，而是免去了他的相位，讓他到同州去當節度使，後來又召他回朝擔任沒有實權的司空。

936年，石敬瑭藉助契丹的力量起兵造反，奪得帝位，建立後晉，馮道再度拜相並受命出使契丹，以表兩國友好。相對於中原的紛亂，契丹顯得兵強馬壯，後晉因借契丹之力建國，必須依附契丹存活，因此馮道的出使成了一個向契丹示好的關鍵。馮道歸國後，石敬瑭便把樞密使廢掉，併入中書省，軍政大權遂集於馮道一身。942年，石重貴繼位，馮道繼續為相，加太尉；後因受讒出為同州節度使，復移鎮南陽，加中書令。

946年，契丹國主耶律德光以石重貴有反意，率大軍南下，翌年滅後晉，馮道又改為侍奉契丹。面對耶律德光的責問及譏諷，馮道憑著他圓滑的態度一一化解，更當上了遼的太傅。期間馮道曾勸阻耶律德光濫殺漢民，使中原漢族免去一場浩劫。

947年，昔日石敬瑭的部下劉知遠於契丹滅後晉後稱帝，建立後漢。同年，遼因為人民反抗不斷而被迫撤兵北還，劉知遠乘機奪取中原。為了拉攏前朝遺老，劉知遠封馮道為太師。951年，劉知遠的手下郭威起兵篡位，建立後周，又拜馮道為太師兼中書令。

954年，郭威駕崩，柴榮繼位，不久即面對遼及北漢聯軍進攻。柴榮力排馮道勸阻，御駕北征抵禦聯軍，大勝。由於馮道諫阻北伐時觸怒柴榮，柴榮鄙視馮道之餘，不讓他隨駕出征北伐，另命他帶病監修太祖郭威陵墓。同年葬禮完畢不久，馮道以七十三歲高齡過世，柴榮為其輟朝三日以示哀悼，追封瀛王，諡文懿。馮道墓位于山西省運城市夏縣捻掌鎮。

史載馮道「三入中書，在相位二十餘年」，「相六帝」（李嗣源、李從厚、石敬瑭、石重貴、郭威及柴榮）。馮道雖身為丞相，卻往往避免過問及參與財政和軍事決策，以免和當權者衝突，因此馮道歷事五朝，只在柴榮計劃北伐時作出唯一一次勸諫。他忠於儒家思想，認為只要恢復傳統，不必有所革新，就可以解決國家問題。

五朝八姓

馮道由後唐莊宗正式入朝起，歷事五朝、八姓、十一帝：

• 「五朝」指後唐、後晉、契丹（滅後晉後定國號「大遼」）、後漢及後周，共五個朝代。

• 「八姓」指後唐李存勗（本姓朱邪）、李嗣源（本姓不詳）及其養子李從珂（本姓王）、後晉石氏、遼國耶律氏、後漢劉氏、後周郭威及其養子柴榮，共八個家族。

• 「十一帝」指以下十一位皇帝：

　• 後唐四代（莊宗李存勗、明宗嗣源、閔帝從厚及末帝從珂）；

　• 後晉兩代（高祖石敬瑭及出帝重貴）；

　• 遼一代（太宗耶律德光）；

　• 後漢兩代（高祖劉知遠及隱帝承祐）；

　• 後周兩代（太祖郭威及世宗柴榮）。

《舊五代史》及《新五代史》不算遼為一朝，共計四朝；《新五代史》把每朝算作一姓，不計耶律德光在內，稱馮道「事四姓十君」。《資治通鑑》稱馮道為相「歷五朝、八姓」。王賡武則稱馮道侍奉「五朝十帝」。

另外，由於馮道於唐末時曾侍奉劉守光，而劉守光亦曾稱帝，國號「大燕」，故又有「十二帝」的說法。

官刻經籍

932年，後唐下令編纂並初次刊印「九經」，這可能不是馮道的主意，而是由另一丞相李愚提出的。

著作

馮道著有《河間集》5卷，文集6卷及詩集10卷，但都不存於後世。晚年的馮道寫了一篇《長樂老自敘》，屬於回憶錄性質，文中將他歷代當過的官職一一列舉並引以為榮，而其在自敘中自稱「長樂老」一事，不論在生前後世都引起過爭議。不過也有說法認為，這個自稱僅是取自於他的出身地長樂郡。

他的另一著作《榮枯鑑》，曾國藩對它的評論是「道盡小人之秘技，人生之榮枯」的一部官場秘笈，並稱此書「使小人汗顏，君子驚悚，實乃二千年不二之異書也。」但自宋以還，各種藝文志及書目中均未載此書；2005年吉林攝影出版社出版此書之前，也不曾見它出版或被其他著作提及。若此書為當代新發現，則亦不見學術界有何反應。其實，包括《榮枯鑒》在內的「天下無謀」書系中的各種謀略之書，都存在此問題。因此，此書可能是當代人託名馮道的偽作；曾國藩的評語，亦不見于其文集，可能是後人附會。

評價

讚揚

馮道在同時代人心目中，是有操守的儒者，甚至是模範丞相。北宋時，《五代通錄》作者范質、薛居正《舊五代史》、吳處厚《青箱雜記》都曾讚揚馮道。范質崇拜馮道，吳處厚則認為馮道有益於世。馮道在事親、濟民、主政、提攜賢良上的表現，都能符合傳統中君子、聖賢的行為標準，這使他在五代時，「當世之士無賢愚皆仰道為元老，而喜為之偁譽」，甚至在死後有著「與孔子同壽」的聲望。

批評

自北宋起，史家因傳統的忠君觀念，對馮道歷事各朝的作為非常不齒。《舊五代史》雖然讚譽馮道的私德及器量，但亦指他不能稱為忠臣。歐陽修《新五代史》則指馮道是五代時道德淪亡的表徵：「其可謂無廉恥者矣」，感嘆當時著名儒者亦欠缺忠貞，甚至基於「不廉則無所不取，不恥則無所不為」，認為馮道的行為亦有份導致天下大亂。司馬光《資治通鑑》更批評不論馮道做過多少好事，亦等於沒有做，因為他只是苟活於世，「乃奸臣之尤」。從此馮道成為歷史上典型的貳臣，為世人嘲笑。清代《續通志》把失節的文武官吏分為十類，馮道列入最壞一類，受指責為「懵大倫而不知恥」。歷史上曾為馮道辯護的只有王世貞、李贄、溫璜等寥寥幾人。可以說在歷史上每逢提起馮道，往往都只有負面的評價。

現代史家觀點

史家王賡武認為馮道「把善意規諫及文雅的奉承兩種藝術糅合到完美的地步」，「他知道怎樣奉承，具有良好幽默感，同時具有一種誠篤的模樣」；馮道「並不是一個傑出的儒者」，他對經典只有「一點有限度的知識，甚至他對儒家之治的了解也似乎是模糊不清的」，是「非常膚淺的儒者」。

近代歷史學家對馮道有了不同的評價，不少人開始為馮道辯護，如近代史學家樊樹志便道：「在一種時局變動甚大的時代，出現馮道式的大臣，並非咄咄怪事。」他認為在五代這種政權變動頻繁的時代，皇帝對臣下的意態往往都沒有多大印象，故出現像馮道這種因事四代十一君而自命為「長樂老」的人，實乃時代的產物。何況以此批評馮道不知廉恥，主要都是從忠君愛國的觀念去看，而從務實的角度來看，馮道的累受重用對五代政局與官僚體制的穩定反而起著正面作用。馮道在契丹任職時，曾力勸契丹官兵不要殺害漢人百姓。另外，他還主持國子監「九經」的刻板印刷工程，歷時22年的改朝換代間也未曾間斷，是中國歷史上首度大規模以官方財力印刷套書。

軼事

有一回，馮道的門客為其講解《老子》，見文章裡面「道可道，非常道」的「道」字，衝犯了馮道的名諱，門客為了避諱，把「道」這個字給改成「不敢說」，於是便將「道可道，非常道」讀作「不敢說，可不敢說，非常不敢說。」

家庭

妻

• 褚氏，前德州戶掾褚濆的女兒，早亡。

• 孫氏，前景州弓高縣令孫師禮的女兒，後漢時封為蜀國夫人。

子女

子

• 馮平

• 馮吉：馮道次子，因不聽馮道勸阻，終日沉迷於彈奏琵琶，被馮道及時人認為不務正業，沒有出息。

• 馮可

• 馮道第四子（早夭）

• 馮義

• 馮正

女

• 馮道長女（下嫁前兵部侍郎崔衍兒子、後漢太僕少卿崔絢）

注釋

參考書目

• 陸揚：〈論馮道的生涯〉。

• 葛劍雄：《往事和近事——亂世的兩難選擇》

• 唐織輝：《中國的奇蹟："政治完人"馮道的為官之道》，人民網，2008年3月3日

• 藍知客：《不生氣的處世之道-「長樂先生」馮道的人生智慧》，中國友誼出版公司，2012年11月

Background and service during Yan

Feng Dao was born in 882, during the reign of Emperor Xizong of Tang. His family was from Jingcheng (景城, in modern Cangzhou, Hebei). His ancestors had been alternatively farmers and scholars. Feng Dao himself was said to be virtuous and tolerant in his youth, studious and capable in writing. He did not look down on poor clothes or food, and was willing to endure hard labor to support his parents and live in poverty. At some point, he was invited by Liu Shouguang, one of the major late-Tang warlords, to serve as a secretary at the prefectural government of Liu's capital You Prefecture (幽州, in modern Beijing).

In 911, by which point Tang had fallen and Liu, having initially been a nominal vassal to the succeeding Later Liang, had declared his own state of Yan as its emperor, Feng was serving as a military advisor to Liu. That year, Liu gathered his troops and prepared to attack Yiwu Circuit (義武, headquartered in modern Baoding, Hebei), which was ruled by its military governor Wang Chuzhi and allied with Later Liang's archenemy Jin. Feng tried to urge Liu not to attack Yiwu, arguing that the time was inopportune. This angered Liu, who threw him in prison, but he was spared his life after others interceded on his behalf. He thereafter fled to Jin, where Zhang Chengye, the chief eunuch advisor to Jin's prince Li Cunxu, recommended him to be the secretary general of Jin's capital Taiyuan.

During Jin/Later Tang

At that time, Li Cunxu was engaged in repeated campaigns to capture territories north of the Yellow River from Later Liang, and the military matters required frequent drafting of orders, which Li entrusted to Feng Dao.

In or around 919, there was an incident where Li had a dispute with his chief military advisor Guo Chongtao, after Guo had opined that Li was inviting too many officers to his meals and that the number should be reduced. In anger, Li responded, "Is it that we do not get to even decide how many of the people who are willing to die for us would be at our meals? Maybe the army should choose a new commander, and we will return to Taiyuan." He asked Feng to draft a declaration to that effect. Feng took his pen but hesitated to write, and he responded to Li, "Your Royal Highness is now planning to conquer the lands south of the Yellow River and then under heavens. Guo Chongtao's request is not overly inappropriate. Even if Your Royal Highness disagreed with him, why make this dispute shock all those near and far, such that our enemies would learn this and believe that you and your subjects are discordant? This cannot be good for your reputation." Soon thereafter, Guo came to apologize, and the matter came to rest. It was said that others became impressed with Feng's temerity in advising the prince. It was also said that Feng lived frugally during these campaigns, living in straw huts with no beds, and sharing his salaries with his staff members. Oftentimes, officers pillaged the region and took beautiful women; sometimes they would give the women to Feng as gifts. Feng would not take the women, but would instead find their families and return them to their families.

In 923, Li declared himself the emperor of a new Later Tang (as Emperor Zhuangzong). He made Feng, along with Lu Zhi (盧質), imperial scholars. After Emperor Zhuangzong conquered Later Liang later in the year and took its territory under his possession, he made Feng Zhongshu Sheren (中書舍人, a mid-level official at the legislative bureau of government (中書省, Zhongshu Sheng)) and deputy minister of census (戶部侍郎, Hubu Shilang). When Feng's father died shortly afterwards, he left governmental service to observe a period of mourning at Jingcheng. At that time, Feng had already become well-known, and the Khitan considered raiding Jingcheng to seize him, but with the Later Tang border forces prepared, the Khitan raid did not actually occur. While he was at Jingcheng, there was a famine in the region. He distributed his wealth to aid the people around him. Also, if there were those who were neglectful in or unable to plow their fields, he would plow their fields for them.

After the end of Feng's mourning period for his father — probably in 926, based on subsequent events — Emperor Zhuangzong summoned Feng back to the imperial government (then at Luoyang) to serve as imperial scholar again. By the time Feng reached the important city Bian Prefecture (汴州, in modern Kaifeng, Henan), however, the Later Tang state was in a state of confusion because of many mutinies that had risen against Emperor Zhuangzong. One of the major rebellions was led by Emperor Zhuangzong's adoptive brother Li Siyuan. Due to the uncertainty, Bian's defender Kong Xun urged Feng to remain at Bian Prefecture until the situation becomes clear, but Feng pointed out that he was under imperial orders to report as soon as possible, so he proceeded to Luoyang. Soon thereafter, Emperor Zhuangzong was killed in a mutiny at Luoyang itself, and Li Siyuan arrived at Luoyang to claim the throne (as Emperor Mingzong).

Emperor Mingzong had long been respectful of Feng's capabilities and virtues. As Emperor Mingzong was himself illiterate, and his chief advisor An Chonghui, while literate, was not well-learned, An recommended setting up a system where chief scholars would advise the emperor on historical and literary matters. Emperor Mingzong thereafter established two posts for imperial scholars at Duanming Hall (端明殿), and commissioned Feng and Zhao Feng to those posts. In 927, Emperor Mingzong further made both Feng and Cui Xie chancellors, with the designation of Tong Zhongshu Menxia Pingzhangshi, along with the title of Zhongshu Shilang (中書侍郎, deputy head of the legislative bureau). (Feng's commission was somewhat of a compromise choice by Emperor Mingzong, as the senior chancellor Ren Huan recommended Li Qi, while Kong, then one of Emperor Mingzong's chiefs of staff (Shumishi) (along with An), pushed for Cui.) While serving as chancellor, Feng often pointed out to Emperor Mingzong the difficulties that farmers faced, and Emperor Mingzong collected the poems that Feng wrote about such difficulties, often having attendants read the poems to him. Emperor Mingzong created him the Duke of Shiping.

In 930, as An had long borne grudges against Emperor Mingzong's adoptive son Li Congke, who was then the military governor (Jiedushi) of Huguo Circuit (護國, headquartered in modern Yuncheng, Shanxi), An encouraged Li Congke's subordinate Yang Yanwen to mutiny and seize Huguo's capital Hezhong (河中), forcing Li Congke to return to Luoyang. An then had Feng and Zhao submit petitions asking for Li Congke to be punished, but Emperor Mingzong refused their request, as well as An's subsequent request for such punishment as well. Later in the year, when Emperor Mingzong and An had more open disputes over the handling of the rebellions by Meng Zhixiang the military governor of Xichuan Circuit (西川, headquartered in modern Chengdu, Sichuan) and Dong Zhang the military governor of Dongchuan Circuit (東川, headquartered in modern Mianyang, Sichuan), An submitted a resignation, which many officials urged him to withdraw. Feng believed that An's best course of action at that time was to resign, and so urged the other officials not to stop An from resigning, but Zhao disagreed and was able to persuade An to remain chief of staff. (Feng turned out to be correct, as in 931, after the rift between Emperor Mingzong and An became greater, Emperor Mingzong had An demoted and then killed.)

In 933, Emperor Mingzong became gravely ill. His oldest son Li Congrong, generally considered his heir presumptive, was fearful that the imperial officials would oppose his succession, and therefore decided to try to seize power by force even before Emperor Mingzong's death. Li Congrong's mutiny ended in failure, and he was killed. Some of the key officials urged for mass execution of Li Congrong's staff members, but Feng Dao and Feng Yun urged leniency, and so most of them were only exiled. Emperor Mingzong died shortly after and was succeeded by his son Li Conghou the Prince of Song (as Emperor Min). Feng Dao continued to serve Emperor Min as chancellor.

In 934, Emperor Min's then-chief advisors, Feng Yun and Zhu Hongzhao, did not want Li Congke, who was then the military governor of Fengxiang Circuit (鳳翔, headquartered in modern Baoji, Shaanxi), and Emperor Min's brother-in-law Shi Jingtang the military governor of Hedong Circuit (河東, headquartered in modern Taiyuan) to be entrenched in their posts, and therefore issued a series of transfer orders that, inter alia, transferred Li Congke to Hedong and Shi to Chengde Circuit (成德, headquartered in modern Shijiazhuang, Hebei). Li Congke considered this a trap, and therefore rebelled against Emperor Min. The imperial army sent to attack him mutinied and joined his rebellion, and he approached Luoyang. Emperor Min fled. As Li Congke was ready to enter Luoyang, Feng Dao, in an action that was criticized both at that time and in posterity, requested the official Lu Dao (盧導) to draft a petition for officials to sign, urging Li Congke to take the throne, which Lu refused to draft and rebuked Feng about. Still, subsequently, an edict was issued in the name of Emperor Mingzong's wife Empress Dowager Cao, deposing Emperor Min and making Li Congke emperor. (Emperor Min was subsequently killed in exile.) Li Congke had Feng Dao serve as the director of Emperor Mingzong's tomb. Once the tomb was completed, he sent Feng out of the capital, to serve as the military governor of Kuangguo Circuit (匡國, headquartered in modern Weinan, Shaanxi), still carrying the Tong Zhongshu Menxia Pingzhangshi title as an honorary title. While at Kuangguo's capital Tong Prefecture (同州), Feng's governance was said to be lenient. In 935, Li Congke recalled him from Kuangguo to serve as Sikong (司空) — a highly honored post as one of the Three Excellencies — but one that lacked real authority. Indeed, as there had long not been anyone who served merely as one of the Three Excellencies without a substantive post (Feng himself had served as Sikong as well when he was chancellor earlier, as an additional title), no one in the imperial government knew what the Sikong was supposed to do. The chancellor Lu Wenji thought that the Sikong was supposed to be in charge of cleaning the altar at imperial sacrifices — a ceremonial duty that Feng stated that he would be honored to carry out — but soon Lu figured out that it was inappropriate to ask the highly honored Feng to actually carry out cleanings, and so did not mention that again.

During Later Jin

In 936, Shi Jingtang, who feared that Li Congke was actually planning to kill him when Li Congke ordered him transferred to Tianping Circuit (天平, headquartered in modern Tai'an, Shandong), rebelled against Li Congke, and with aid from Khitan's Emperor Taizong, soon declared himself emperor of a new state of Later Jin (as its Emperor Gaozu), defeated Later Tang troops that Li Congke sent against him, and approached Luoyang. Li Congke committed suicide, along with his wife Empress Liu, his children, and Empress Dowager Cao. The new Later Jin emperor entered Luoyang. Later in the year, he gave Feng Dao, in addition to nonsubstantive Sikong title, the titles Tong Zhongzhu Menxia Pingzhangshi and Menxia Shilang (門下侍郎, deputy head of the examination bureau (門下省, Menxia Sheng)), thus making him chancellor again.

In 938, Emperor Gaozu honored the Khitan emperor to be "father emperor" while referring to himself as "son emperor," and also offered honored titles to Emperor Taizong's mother Empress Dowager Shulü Ping. As a sign of further respect, he sent Feng and another senior official, Liu Xu to Khitan to offer those honors, as well as gifts, to the emperor and empress dowager. (This mission was despite Emperor Gaozu's reservation that Emperor Taizong, impressed by Feng, might detain him. Feng pointed out that given Khitan's aid to Emperor Gaozu, he was willing to take the risk on the emperor's behalf. Emperor Taizong did consider doing so but eventually allowed Feng to return to Later Jin.)

In 939, Emperor Gaozu abolished the office of Shumishi, believing that it had grown overly powerful, and gave its powers to chancellors, particularly Feng. He was soon given the titles of Situ (司徒, also one of the Three Excellencies) and Shizhong (侍中, head of the examination bureau), and created the Duke of Lu. It was said that at one point, Feng offered to resign on account of illness, and Emperor Gaozu sent his nephew Shi Chonggui the Prince of Zheng — the most honored male member of the imperial family at that point as Emperor Gaozu's sons, except for the young Shi Chongrui, had all been killed either in his own rebellion against Later Tang or been killed in rebellions against him — to dissuade Feng from resigning, and further relayed, through Shi Chongrui, the comment, "If you do not return, I will personally come visit you." It was only after this that Feng returned to the government to continue to serve as chancellor, and it was said that no one was more honored in the administration. It was said that, around this time, Feng and another chancellor, Li Song, recommended Emperor Gaozu's brother-in-law Du Chongwei, who was then the deputy commander of the imperial guards, to take over as the commander, displacing the general Liu Zhiyuan, and thus drew resentment from Liu.

Because Shi Chongrui was young, Emperor Gaozu never designated him as heir. However, in 942, when Emperor Gaozu grew ill, he summoned Feng, had Shi Chongrui come out to bow to Feng, and put Shi Chongrui in Feng's lap, hinting strongly that he wanted Feng to support Shi Chongrui to succeed him. However, after Emperor Gaozu soon died, Feng discussed the matter with the imperial guard general Jing Yanguang. Feng and Jing both opined that given the perilous state that Later Jin was in at that time, an older emperor was needed. They thus supported Shi Chonggui, who then carried the title of Prince of Qi, to be emperor. Shi Chonggui gave Feng the honorary title of Taiwei (太尉, also one of the Three Excellencies) and created him the Duke of Yan.

Shi Chonggui, contrary to the humble posture that Emperor Gaozu took with Khitan, took a more hostile posture toward Khitan. In particular, whereas Emperor Gaozu referred to himself as "son" and "your subject" when writing Emperor Taizong, Shi Chonggui took the position advocated by Jing, that he should only refer to himself as "grandson" and not "your subject" — in other words, leaving the personal relationship intact but at the same time disavowing that Later Jin was a vassal to Khitan. Li Song tried to argue against this stance, but with Feng not opposing or supporting it, Shi Chonggui's letter to Emperor Taizong notifying that Emperor Gaozu had died and that he had succeeded Emperor Gaozu referred to himself only as grandson. This displeased Emperor Taizong, who wrote back, rebuking Shi Chonggui for taking the throne without Khitan approval. Emperor Taizong took no hostile military action at that time, but by 944, with his general Zhao Yanshou encouraging a campaign and with Emperor Taizong promising Zhao that he would be made the emperor of the Central Plains if he succeeded, there began to be repeated Khitan incursions into Later Jin territory. With Feng considered an indecisive chancellor not willing to make decisions, Shi Chonggui sent him back to Kuangguo to serve as its military governor, carrying the Shizhong title as an honorary chancellor title. After about a year there, he was transferred to Weisheng Circuit (威勝, headquartered in modern Nanyang, Henan), carrying the title of Zhongshu Ling (中書令, head of the legislative bureau) as an honorary chancellor title.

During Liao incursion

In 946, after defeating and then persuading Du Wei (i.e., Du Chongwei, who had removed the "Chong" character from his name to observe naming taboo), whom Shi Chonggui had commissioned as the commander of a major anti-Khitan army, to surrender, Khitan's Emperor Taizong advanced all the way south to the Later Jin capital Kaifeng, forcing Shi Chonggui to surrender. In 947, Emperor Taizong took the clothes of a Chinese emperor and declared himself Emperor of Liao (i.e., not using the Khitan name any more), effectively showing his intent to be the emperor of China proper as well, and summoned the Later Jin military governors to Kaifeng to meet him. Feng Dao, who was then still at Weisheng, did so. As both Zhao Yanshou and Zhang Li had recommended Li Song, Emperor Taizong treated both Feng and Li with respect. He made Li Shumishi, while giving Feng Dao the capital of acting Taifu (太傅) and had him, while not officially be Shumishi, work out of that office and consult on important matters. It was said that there was a conversation where Emperor Taizong asked him, "How do I save all people under the heaven?" Feng responded, "At this time, not even if the Buddha reentered the world can the people be saved, but only the Emperor can save them." It was believed that these words, along with the intercession of Zhao, was the reason why Emperor Taizong did not carry out mass executions of the Han people. When the Later Jin general Liu Jixun, whom Emperor Taizong blamed for participating in Shi Chonggui's planning for the anti-Khitan campaign, Liu tried to blame Feng and Jing Yangguang for being behind the campaign; Emperor Taizong rebuked Liu for blaming Feng, and had him delivered to the northern Khitan city of Huanglong (黃龍, in modern Changchun, Jilin).

By spring 947, however, Emperor Taizong was faced with numerous Han mutinies due to his harsh raids against the population. He decided to leave his brother-in-law Xiao Han in charge of Kaifeng while he himself took the Later Jin wealth and its key officials north, back to Liao proper. He died on the way, and the Liao generals supported his nephew Yelü Ruan as his successor (as Emperor Shizong). Emperor Shizong, after arresting Zhao (who had wanted to take the throne himself) thereafter declared himself emperor. Meanwhile, Liu Zhiyuan, in this power vacuum, declared himself emperor of a new Later Han (as its Emperor Gaozu) and advanced south, quickly entering Kaifeng after Xiao withdrew from it, and took over most of Later Jin territory.

Meanwhile, Empress Dowager Shulü opposed Emperor Shizong's ascension and sent an army against him. He defeated her army, and subsequently put her under house arrest. During the campaign, however, he left the general Yelü Mada in charge of Heng Prefecture (恆州, in modern Shijiazhuang), where Feng, along with other former Later Jin chancellors Li Song and He Ning, had remained. Yelü Mada was corrupt and harsh, and also put the Han soldiers under severe restrictions, drawing their discontent. When Emperor Shizong subsequently sent an order for the Later Jin officials to continue to advance north to attend to Emperor Taizong's funeral, the Han soldiers mutinied under the leadership of the officer Bai Zairong (白再榮). During the battle inside Heng Prefecture, at the urging of Li Gu, Feng, Li Song, and He Ning personally went to encourage the soldiers to fight, and it was said that that raised the morale of the Han soldiers, who subsequently defeated Yelü Mada and forced him to flee with his remaining Khitan soldiers. The soldiers subsequently offered the military governorship of the region (Chengde Circuit (成德)) to Feng, but Feng declined, pointing out that a military officer should do so, so Bai claimed the title of acting military governor, and subsequently submitted to Later Han.

During Later Han

Feng Dao, Li Song, and He Ning subsequently went to then-Later Han capital Kaifeng. Emperor Gaozu immediately commissioned Li Song and He Ning with honorary titles (albeit not substantive ones), but did not commission Feng until spring 948 (when he gave Feng the even more honored title of Taishi (太師), but no substantive offices).

At the time of Emperor Gaozu's death in spring 948 (shortly after Feng was commissioned Taishi), Emperor Gaozu had left directions to the officials and generals he entrusted his son Liu Chengyou (Emperor Yin) to (Su Fengji, Yang Bin, Shi Hongzhao, and Guo Wei) to watch Du Chongwei (who had restored his original name after Later Jin's fall) closely, and shortly after Emperor Gaozu's death, the four, announcing the order as an order from Emperor Gaozu, had Du put to death. This caused great apprehension to Li Shouzhen, who had also become a Later Han subject. Later in spring 948, Li therefore rebelled at his post as military governor of Huguo and claimed the title of Prince of Qin, in alliance with Wang Jingchong the military governor of Fengxiang and Zhao Siwan, a rebel officer who had seized control of Jinchang Circuit (晉昌, headquartered in modern Xi'an, Shaanxi). The leading officials decided to have Guo lead the imperial guard troops against Li. Before Guo departed, he went to see Feng to request Feng's opinion; Feng opined to him that since Li had long led the imperial guards that Guo would be commanding, he needed to destroy their affinity to Li by rewarding them greatly regardless of impact on the imperial treasury. Guo agreed, and it was said that this move made Guo popular among the imperial guards such that Li had no ability to sway them. Guo was thereafter able to defeat Li in 949, and Li committed suicide; Wang subsequently also did so, and Zhao, after initially surrendering to Later Han forces sent against him, reconsidered, and was then killed by Later Han troops, ending the three rebellions.

In 950, Feng wrote an autobiographical note titled the Self-Description of the Old Man from Changle that discussed family history and his career, including the honors that had been bestowed on him and his family members by the succeeding dynasties. (This text drew severe criticism from the later Song Dynasty historians Ouyang Xiu (the lead editor of the New History of the Five Dynasties) and Sima Guang (the lead editor of the Zizhi Tongjian), both of whom described Feng as disloyal and the most wicked among officials as a result.)

In winter 950, Emperor Yin, angry that Yang, Shi, and Guo, along with the chancellor Wang Zhang, had held onto power and not let him make decisions alone, had Yang, Shi, and Wang killed. Guo, who was commanding an army to the north and not at the capital Kaifeng at that time, escaped the fate, but Emperor Yin still had his family and that of Guo's army monitor Wang Jun killed. Guo thereafter rebelled and took the army toward Kaifeng, defeating the imperial army that Emperor Yin personally commanded to face him. Emperor Yin fled and was killed in flight. When Guo subsequently entered the capital, Feng did not bow to him, but accepted his bows, stating to him calmly, "This trip you, Shizhong, undertook, was not an easy one." This apparently set back Guo's plan to take the throne himself, and Guo subsequently led the officials to greet Emperor Gaozu's wife Empress Dowager Li, who decreed that Emperor Gaozu's nephew Liu Yun, whom Emperor Gaozu had adopted as a son and who was then the military governor of Wuning Circuit (武寧, headquartered in modern Xuzhou, Jiangsu), be made emperor. She then sent Feng, along with the officials Wang Du (王度) and Zhao Shangjiao, to Wuning's capital Xu Prefecture (徐州) to escort Liu Yun back to the capital to take the throne.

However, the officers under Guo were largely against supporting another member of the Liu family as emperor, as they were fearful of being punished for having sacked the capital. They subsequently mutinied at Chan Prefecture (澶州, in modern Puyang, Henan) and supported Guo as emperor. Guo accepted, and headed back into Kaifeng, softening Empress Dowager Li's resistance by promising to honor her like a mother, while sending his officer Guo Chongwei to intercept Liu Yun's train. When Guo Chongwei arrived, he took over Liu Yun's escorting forces and delivered Guo Wei's orders, summoning Feng back to the capital, leaving Liu Yun with Zhao and Wang, and effectively putting Liu Yun under house arrest. (Liu Yun was later killed.) In spring 951, Guo Wei took the throne as Emperor Taizu of a new Later Zhou.

During Later Zhou

Shortly after the new Later Zhou emperor took the throne, he made Feng Dao Zhongshu Ling, thus restoring him to chancellorship.

Later in the year, the general Murong Yanchao, a half brother of Later Han's Emperor Gaozu, who initially submitted to Later Zhou, rebelled at Taining Circuit (泰寧, headquartered in modern Jining, Shandong). After Murong was defeated and committed suicide in early 952, Emperor Taizu considered slaughtering Murong's soldiers. However, the imperial scholar Dou Yi (竇儀) met with Feng and fellow chancellor Fan Zhi and persuaded them to argue to Emperor Taizu (along with Dou himself) that the Taining soldiers were merely forced into combat by Murong. They were able to persuade Emperor Taizu, who thereafter pardoned the Taining soldiers.

Later that year, another imperial scholar, Xu Taifu (許台符), had requested that Ge Yanyu (葛延遇) and Li Cheng (李澄), who had falsely accused Li Song of plotting to join Li Shouzhen's rebellion in 948 and whose false accusations led to the slaughter of Li Song and his family, be put to death. Feng opined that there had been a chance in dynasties and many general pardons in the interim, so the charges should not be pursued. However, fellow chancellor Wang Jun was impressed by Xu's fervor to avenge Li Song, and recommended Ge's and Li Cheng's death. Emperor Taizu thereafter put Ge and Li Cheng to death.

In 953, believing that Wang was growing too powerful and too insolent in his behavior (including trying to prevent Emperor Taizu's adoptive son Guo Rong from coming to the capital Kaifeng to pay homage to the emperor, in fear of Guo Rong's diverting powers from him), Emperor Taizu, after consulting with Feng and the other chancellors, forced Wang into medical retirement. (After Wang's retirement and subsequent death, Guo Rong was able to stay at the capital and thereafter would remain in the power center.)

Emperor Taizu died in 954 and was succeeded by Guo Rong (as Emperor Shizong). Shortly after Emperor Shizong's enthronement, even before Emperor Taizu's burial, Li Yun's biological father Liu Min (né Liu Chong), who had declared himself emperor and legitimate successor of the Later Han throne at Taiyuan, shortly after Emperor Taizu's proclamation of Later Zhou (and whose state, while claiming to be a continuation of Later Han, became known historically as Northern Han), decided to launch a major attack on Later Zhou with Liao support, hoping to reestablish Han control over the central plains. Emperor Shizong decided to react by personally leading an army against Liu Min. Feng and many other officials had reservations about having the new emperor personally lead the army (arguing that Emperor Shizong's absence may lead to other rebellions), which led to a heated exchange recorded by historians between Emperor Shizong and Feng:

The tone of the exchange displeased Emperor Shizong, but the chancellor Wang Pu agreed with Emperor Shizong's idea of personally leading an army, and so Emperor Shizong did so anyway. As Emperor Shizong was ready to depart, he commissioned Feng to be in charge of accompanying Emperor Taizu's casket to the imperial tomb and overseeing its burial. Emperor Shizong ended up crushing the Northern Han army on the campaign, while Feng died before Emperor Shizong's victorious return.

Contribution to the development of printing

In 932, Feng Dao ordered the Confucian classics printed using movable wood blocks. About a century after the invention of block-printing, Feng Dao significantly improved the printing process, and utilized it as a political tool. (The project was completed in 953, when the completed printing blocks were presented to Emperor Taizu of Later Zhou.) He is generally regarded as the inventor of modern printing in China, as Johannes Gutenberg is in the West. The first standard edition of the Confucian classics with commentary was published in 130 volumes between 932 and 953 in Xi'an. The improved printing technology quickly spread, and the earliest known Korean book was printed in 950.

"The work of Feng Tao and his associates for printing in China may be compared to the work of Gutenberg in Europe. There had been printing before Gutenberg − block printing certainly and very likely experimentation in typography also − but Gutenberg's Bible heralded a new day in the civilization of Europe. In the same way there had been printing before Feng Tao, but it was an obscure art that had little effect on the culture of the country. Feng Tao's Classics made printing a power that ushered in the renaissance of the Sung era." (The version of the text that Feng used came from the text that the Tang chancellor Zheng Tan had ordered carved on stone at then-Tang capital Chang'an.)